Ask an expert · answers

Questions, answered by practising CAs

Real situations from business owners and professionals, answered in writing and reviewed before they are published. Read the answer, then ask about your own case.

33 questions answered 15 topics 2–3 working days, typically Free, no account

33 answers

Ask, free
Payroll, PF & ESI Noida

We have grown to 22 employees. Are PF and ESI now compulsory, and what do they cost us?

In short

Both, and the clock started the month you reached 20.

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 6 Aug 2026 Read →
GST registration & returns Chennai

Our GSTR-2B shows ₹3.4 lakh less ITC than our purchase register because two suppliers have not filed GSTR-1. Can we still claim it?

In short

No. Since 1 January 2022, section 16(2)(aa) read with rule 36(4) allows input tax credit only for invoices that appear in your GSTR-2B. A valid invoic...

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 3 Aug 2026 Read →
Income tax & ITR filing Pune

Selling a flat bought in 2012 for ₹38 lakh at ₹1.1 crore. How much capital gains tax, and how can I save it?

In short

This is a long-term gain (held more than 24 months) and, because you bought before 23 July 2024, you get to choose the lower of two computations.

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 2 Aug 2026 Read →
Company / LLP registration Bengaluru

Private limited or LLP for a two-founder SaaS startup that plans to raise an angel round next year?

In short

If a funding round is realistically on the roadmap, incorporate a private limited company from day one.

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 29 Jul 2026 Read →
ROC & company law compliance Bengaluru

We incorporated a private limited company in January and have no revenue yet. Which ROC filings are compulsory this year, and what happens if we miss them?

In short

Everything below applies even with zero revenue; the Companies Act does not have a dormant-by-default state.

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 26 Jul 2026 Read →
TDS / TCS compliance Hyderabad

Is TDS applicable when our partnership firm pays ₹45,000 a month office rent to an individual landlord?

In short

Not at this rent. From 1 April 2025 the threshold under section 194-I rose from ₹2.4 lakh to ₹6 lakh a year. ₹45,000 a month is ₹5.4 lakh, so no deduc...

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 22 Jul 2026 Read →
Income tax & ITR filing Mumbai

Old or new tax regime for FY 2026-27? Salary ₹14 lakh, HRA, 80C ₹1.5 lakh and ₹2 lakh home-loan interest.

In short

Run the numbers both ways; with your figures the new regime still wins, but it is closer than most people expect.

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 21 Jul 2026 Read →
GST registration & returns Surat

We sell sarees on Amazon to customers all over India. Is GST registration compulsory when our turnover is only ₹9 lakh?

In short

Yes, you need to register, and the reason is not the turnover limit but the nature of the sales.

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 16 Jul 2026 Read →
GST registration & returns Pune

Do I need GST registration for freelance design work billed only to US clients?

In short

Short answer: you must register once your aggregate turnover crosses ₹20 lakh in a financial year, and even then you will not charge your US clients G...

ERPCA ERPCA Expert Desk · 15 Jul 2026 Read →

Did not find your situation?

Post it free. Practising CA, CS and tax professionals answer in writing; every answer is reviewed before it is published.

Ask an expert, free